Memorials

-


Boer War Memorial Sculpture
Cannon Hill Park
The 'memorial statue' has become the subject of contention over the past few years, as the rewriting of history, providing us with alternative details of a particular event, gathers pace. 

Edward Colston in Bristol

Robert Milligan at West India Dock Quay

Cecil Rhodes at Oriel College, Oxford

To name a few-

Most, if not all statues of this kind represent either an occasion or an individual for actions deemed celebratory in their day, yet as successive generations awaken to further revelations, the discussions can take a turn in another direction, and we begin to question other aspects and related facts. A broader section of our previously unvoiced society is able to voice opinions according to a different perspective.

https://www.historyandpolicy.org/opinion-articles/articles/the-fall-of-slavery-statues-symbols-and-social-contention 

The article - 'The fall of slavery: statues, symbols and social contention' - addresses the issues. Follow the link above

Attached to the Boer War Memorial in 2020

The Boer War Memorial at Cannon Hill Park contains a cartouche with the words-

"TO / THE GLORIOUS MEMORY / OF THE / SONS OF BIRMINGHAM / WHO FELL IN THE SOUTH AFRICAN WAR 1899-1902 / AND TO PERPETUATE / THE EXAMPLE OF ALL WHO / SERVED IN THE WAR / THIS MEMORIAL IS ERECTED / BY THEIR FELLOW CITIZENS".

During the Black Lives Matter campaign in 2020, a laminated A3 sheet was attached to the memorial (image above) reinforcing the sentiment of sadness and adding another detail in remembrance of the Black South Africans who lost lives, together with a reminder that it was "two European colonising powers" in a conflict in a foreign land. This is known as an "unofficial modification" and avoids the sometimes vandalistic options, such as defacing or graffiti or physical destruction.

This, I feel, is an appropriate and necessary addition to the story, albeit a temporary one, as the sheet was taken down and discarded nearby, deliberately I suspect.

But rather than the destruction of offending statues, as was the case with the statue of Edward Colston in Bristol, although that's now part of the narrative, a brief and respectful modification is called for, one that does nothing to damage the integrity of the artwork, but adds perspective and value to the overall story.

Comments

  1. Anonymous18 December 2022 at 04:56

    I agree completely and hope that a similar modification/text will be added permanently.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Anonymous28 December 2022 at 01:42

    Me too

    ReplyDelete

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Brockley Grove - then and now

-
Image
Holders Woods and Fields east of centre with Brockley Grove to the south, road and turning circle Article from Birmingham Forum website -  My old mum and I moved into a prefab on Brockley grove just off dog pool lane (dads lane) in moseley in about 1959 and my old mum thought it was heaven, it had a "fitted kitchen" i.e a built in washing machine, she'd always had to do her washing by hand before and in both bedrooms were "metal" fitted wardrobes. As it was detached, standing surounded with a nice little garden we both loved it. unfortunatly it' now been demolished and  Brockley grove is now unsign posted and is a dog walking area but I will always have very fond memories of mom's little "bungalow". This map shows the layout of the Brockley Grove prefabs
Read more

New Trees - Woodland Wednesdays at Highbury

-
Image
Highbury Park and neighbours - wooded Wooded Highbury The term 'replete' has recently been used in reference to the wildlife provision at Highbury, and whilst the park can boast a healthy list of trees and bird life and perhaps reasonable opportunity for invertebrates, there is certainly room for enhancement and improvement in this regard. The park is jealously viewed and guarded by its regular visitors and protest quickly develops as changes occur - for example recently planted hedges were met with anxiety and vandalism, new desire lines are seen as trespass and the recently announced proposal to improve the tarmac surfacing for cyclists was greeted with the following- https://www.birminghambeheard.org.uk/place/bcr3-highbury-park-walking-and-cycling-route Consultation  Politics aside, if that's possible, an overview of the wooded fabric of the park would probably indicate a net loss of timber over the past 5 years due to ageing, and the need to 'mak
Read more

Do you know your Christmas Trees? (part 2)

-
Image
Fir at Cannon Hill Park possibly Abies grandis Winter 'evergreens', a suitable and seasonal distraction in terms of identification, providing a rather more challenging activity than the now fallen broad leaves, although having said that, a tree with no leaves is just as challenging when only buds and bark are at play. Also, the language of evergreens is somewhat different to that of broadleaves, in both biological terminology and description, providing a continual monologue through the year, with a voice that changes less hysterically than its broadleaf distant relatives. The other challenging difficulty of course is the weather, standing with a field guide and key on a cold day is not everyone's idea of fun. The subject trees related to in this passage are mainly those found locally either at the Cannon Hill Park Tree Trail or at the Highbury Park Pinetum and Highbury Estate.  All of the trees have been introduced with various planting schemes over the past 80 years or so,
Read more